Developing Effective Scenarios for Reducing Inequality in the Provision of Public Services in Urban regions of Urmia through a Futures Research Approach

Mohammad Rezapour, Behrouz; Mousavi, Mir Najaf

Developing Effective Scenarios for Reducing Inequality in the Provision of Public Services in Urban regions of Urmia through a Futures Research Approach

Document Type : Origional Article

Authors

Behrouz Mohammad Rezapour ¹ ^¶

Mir Najaf Mousavi ²

¹ Ph.D. Student in Land Use Planning, Department of Geography, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Urmia University , Urmia , Iran

² Professor of Department, Geography and urban Planning, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Urmia University, Urmia, Iran

Abstract

Background and Objective: Urban public services are key elements in shaping the physical, social, and spatial structure of cities. In many urban Regions, especially in developing countries, access to services such as healthcare, education, transportation, and infrastructure is significantly unequal. The main objective of this study is to identify the key factors contributing to inequality in the provision of public services in the study area Urmia city and to develop future-oriented scenarios using futures research tools.
Methodology:This applied futures study employs a descriptive, analytical, and exploratory research approach. In the first stage, the TOPSIS ranking model was used to evaluate and rank the five urban regions based on their level of public services. Subsequently, possible future scenarios were generated using the MicMac and Scenario Wizard software.
Results and Findings: The results indicate that Region Five has the highest level of desirability, Regions One and Four are in a moderate state, and Regions Two and Three are in an unfavorable condition. Scenario analysis reveals two contrasting paths: a favorable scenario characterized by transparency, anti-corruption measures, and equitable resource distribution, which leads to reduced service gaps and improved access; and a crisis scenario marked by budget concentration in select Regions and institutional weakness, which intensifies inequalities. The study underscores the urgent need for action to address disparities in public service distribution and to ensure equitable access to essential urban facilities for all citizens, regardless of geographic location or economic status.

Keywords

Social Justice"

"Inequality"

"Urban Public Services"

"Scenario Planning"

"Futures Studies"

"Urmia City"

Subjects

Town and country planning (Spatial Organization)

Asghari Zamani,A. & Karimi,R. (2023). Analysis of the Physical-Social Arrangement of Power in Urban Regions (Case Study: Five Regions of Urmia City). The Journal of Spatial Planning and Geomatics, 27(2), 1-27. )In Persian(. doi: 10.2022/hsmsp.27.2.1

Aftab, A. (2023). Approaches and methods of futurology and scenario planning in urban and regional planning. Geography and Regional Future Studies, 1(1), 82-107. )In Persian(. doi: 10.30466/ grfs. 2023. 121360

Afsharnia, A. , Zebardast, E. & Talachian, M. (2022). Explaining the concept of spatial justice in the implementation of comprehensive urban plans (Case study: Golpayegan city). Geographical Urban Planning Research (GUPR), 9(4), 981-1008. )In Persian(. doi: 10.22059/jurbangeo. 2021.320480.1478

Anabestani,A. & َAnabestani,Z. (2022). Analysis of Key Drivers Affecting the Increase of Effectiveness of Strategic-Operational Plans of Cities and Municipalities with a Futures Study Approach in Cities of Khorasan Razavi Province. Journal of Sustainable Urban & Regional Development Studies (JSURDS), 2(4), 43-68. )In Persian(.

Ashik, F. R., Mim, S. A., & Neema, M. N. (2020(. Towards vertical spatial equity of urban facilities: An integration of spatial and aspatial accessibility. Journal of Urban Management, 9(1), 77–92. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jum.2019.11.004

Ahmadi, M. & Shamsipour, A. A. (2020). Analysis of spatial distribution of public services in terms of spatial justice approach (Case study: Bojnourd). Geographical Urban Planning Research (GUPR), 8(1), 73-98. )In Persian(. doi: 10.22059/jurbangeo.2020.273616.1041

Asghari Zamani, Akbar, Alizadeh Zenouzi, Shahin, & GHorbani, Rasoul. (2019). Ranking Urban Areas Based on the Distribution of Land use and Urban Services and its Impact on Population Spatial Distribution (A Case Study of the regions of Marand). ENVIRONMENTAL BASED TERRITORIAL PLANNING (AMAYESH), 11(43), 1-20. )In Persian(.

Abdollahi, A. A. & Ghasemi, M. (2018). Analysis of Spatial Distribution of Urban Public Services using Techniques of Vikor and Was Pas (Case Study: Kerman). Geographical Urban Planning Research (GUPR), 6(4), 695-715. )In Persian(. doi: 10.22059/jurbangeo.2018.238858.762

Bandarabad,A. & Khaliji,M. A. (2018). Measuring social justice with a sustainable development approach Case study of Tabriz urban areas. Sustainable city, 1(1), 77-89. )In Persian(. doi: 10.22034/jsc.2018.87369

Curtis, C., & Scheurer, J. (2010). Planning for sustainable accessibility: Developing tools to aid discussion and decision-making. Prog. Plan. 74(2), 53–106. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. progress .2010.05.001

Ebrahim parvar, M. , Majedi, H. & Zarabadi, Z. S. S. (2024). Explanation of the Physical -Spatial Justice Components of a Justice-Oriented City with an Emphasis on the Knowledge - Power Theory, Case Study: the Five Districts of Rasht City. Urban Planning Knowledge, 8(1), 62-86. )In Persian(. doi: 10.22124/ upk. 2024.25410.1883

Ebrahimi,A. & amanpour,S. (2023). Evaluation and analysis of the distribution of government administrative uses in the city of Ahvaz with an empirical approach. Geography and Human Relationships, 6(3), 933-946. )In Persian(. doi: 10.22034/gahr.2023.405612.1904

Fayos, E., Blanco, H., & da Silva, F. A. (2024). Challenges and approaches in applying spatial justice to urban planning. Planning Theory & Practice. https://doi.org /10.1080/14649357. 2024. 2341254

Gonzalez-Feliu, J., Salanova Grau, J. M., & Beziat, A. (2014). A location-based accessibility analysis to estimate the suitability of urban consolidation facilities. Int. J. Urban Sci. 18 (2), 166–185. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/12265934.2014.930673

Godet, M., & Durance, P. (2011). Strategic Foresight for Corporate and Regional Development. Dunod.

Harvey, David. (1990). Social Justice & the City. Translated by Mohammad Reza Haeri, Farrokh Hesamian, & Behrouz Manadizadeh. Tehran: Pardazah and Urban Planning Company.) In Persian(.

Harvey, D. (1973). Social Justice and the City. Edward Arnold.

Jian, Izzy & Luo, Jiemei & Chan, Edwin. (2020). Spatial justice in public open space planning: Accessibility and inclusivity. Habitat International. 102122. 10.1016/j.habitatint.2020 . 102122.

Khaksari, A. , Masoumifar, A. H. & Assayesh, M. (2021). Analysis of Spatial Justice in Urban Services Provision in Iran. Human Geography Research, 53(3), 793-810. )In Persian(. doi: 10.22059/jhgr.2020. 296238.1008074

Kananpour, A. , Masoumi, M. & Nazmfar, H. (2021). Investigation of Spatial Justice in the allocation of Urban Land Uses (Case Study: the five municipality regions of Ardabil City). Geographical Urban Planning Research (GUPR), 9(3), 637-662.) In Persian(. doi: 10.22059/jurbangeo. 2021.315186.1420

Kelobonyea, K., McCarneya, G., Xia, J., Swapan, M. S. H., Mao, F., & Zhoua, H. (2019). Relative accessibility analysis for key land uses: A spatial equity perspective. Journal of Transport Geography, 75, 82–93. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2019.01.015

Lee, J., & Miller, H. J. (2018). Measuring the impacts of new public transit services on space-time accessibility: An analysis of transit system redesign and new bus rapid transit in Columbus, Ohio, USA. Applied Geography, 93(February), 47–63. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/ j. apgeog. 2018.02.012

Lin Brenda, Meyers Jacqui, Barnett Guy, (2015), understandinding the potential loss inquities of green space distribution with urban densificationT urban forestry and urban greening 14, 952-958.

Manoochehri MiyandoAb, A. , Nouri, Z. , javan, K. & Ramezani Mehrian, M. (2025). An analysis of distributive justice and its impact on access to urban services: Urmia city. Journal of Urban Ecology Researches, 16(40), -.) In Persian(. doi: 10.30473/grup.2024.70309.2827

Mousavi, M., Jafarpour Ghalehteimouri, K., Bagheri Kashkouli, A., & Bayramzadeh, N. (2024). Mitigating development barriers and addressing disparities in border cities of Iran: a comprehensive analysis of border provinces and influential factors. Geojournal, 89(4), 1–20. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10708-024-11181-9.

Mousavi, M.N.; Omidvarfar, S.; Hoseinzadeh, R.; Bayramzadeh, N. (2022). Analysis of Spatial Justice in the Distribution of Service Uses in Urban Areas (Case Study: 5 Regions - Urmia), Journal of Geography and Environmental Studies, 11 (43), 162-177.) In Persian(. Dor: 20.1001.1. 20087845.1401.11.43.10.1

Ministry of Housing & Urban Development. (2010). Urmia City Master Plan: Volume 2 of the Revised Plan. Prepared by Consulting Engineers of Architecture and Urban Planning, Tarh and Amayesh.) In Persian(.

Miles, I., Saritas, O., & Sokolov, A. (2008). Foresight for science, technology and innovation. Futures, 40(1), 1–3.

Nazari Amestejan,K. , Mosavi,M. N. & Taghilo,A. A. (2024). Formulation of drivers and scenarios affecting population policies in West Azarbaijan Province with a spatial planning approach. Journal of Sustainable Urban & Regional Development Studies (JSURDS), 5(3), 1-16.) In Persian(.

OECD. (2015). The Metropolitan Century: Understanding Urbanisation and its Consequences. OECD Publishing.

Patel, K., & Manvi, N. (2022). Influence and Depiction of Power in an Urban Space, International Journal of Architectural and Environmental Engineering, 16 (3), 1. https://publications. waset. org/abstracts/145987.

Planning and Planning Consulting Engineers. (2019). Detailed Integrated Plan of Urmia City. Commissioned by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development and the Housing and Urban Development Organization of West Azerbaijan Province.) In Persian(.

Popper, R. (2008). Foresight Methodology. In the Handbook of Technology Foresight.

Rostaei, S. & Alizadeh, S. (2020). Measurement of Spatial Equity in Public Services between Different Cities of West Azerbaijan Province. Journal of Geography and Planning, 24(71), 151-171. )In Persian(. doi: 10.22034/gp.2020.10535

Saberi, A. , Pourahmad, A. & zanganeh Shahraki, S. (2024). Analyzing the distribution of urban services and identifying drivers affecting spatial justice with a Future study approach (case study: Yasouj city). Journal of Geography and Planning, 28(88), 191-164. )In Persian(. doi: 10.22034/gp.2023. 54478. 3068

Setavand M H, Hajizadeh F,& Yaghfoori H. (2019). Spatial analysis of Shiraz urban areas in terms of social justice with an emphasis on public services. jgs. 19(52), 171-192. )In Persian(. doi:10.29252/jgs.19.52.171

Soja, Edward. (2018). In Search of Spatial Justice: From the City Level to the Trans-Region. Translated by Abuzar Salami-Bairami, Ahad Ebrahim Pourlanbaran, & Mahboobeh Soleimanzadeh. Tehran: Akhtar Publications.) In Persian(.

Statistical Center of Iran. (2016). Results of the General Population and Housing Census, 2016. Tehran: Statistical Center of Iran.) In Persian(.

Soja, E. W. (2010). Seeking Spatial Justice. University of Minnesota Press.

Turok, I., & McGranahan, G. (2013). Urbanization and economic growth: the arguments and evidence for Africa and Asia. Environment and Urbanization, 25(2), 465-482.

Tsou, K. W., Hung, Y. T., & Chang, Y.L. (2005). An accessibility-based integrated measure of relative spatial equity in urban public facilities. Cities, 22(6), 424–435. https://doi.org/ 10. 1016/ j. cities.2005.07.004

Urmia Municipality. (2025). Library Documents. Urmia: Municipality Documents Center. )In Persian(.

UN-Habitat. (2020). World Cities Report 2020: The Value of Sustainable Urbanization. Retrieved from https://unhabitat.org

Yi Jian, I., Luo, J., Chan, E. H. W., (2020), Spatial justice in public open space planning: Accessibility and inclusivity, Habitat International, 97.

Zhang, X., Lu, Y., Xu, Y., Zhou, C., & Zou, Y. (2024). Governing regional inequality through regional cooperation? A case study of the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macau Greater Bay area. Appl. Geogr., 162, 103135. doi: 10.1016/j.apgeog.2023.103135

Zhang, R., Sun, F., Shen, Y., Peng, Sh., & Che, Y. (2021). Accessibility of urban park benefits with different spatial coverage: Spatial and social inequity, Applied Geography 135 (2021) 102555. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.apgeog.2021.102555